Milk Can Hamburgers & Frozen Custard Menu (2025 Update)
Introducing the Menu at Milk Can Hamburgers & Frozen Custard
Nestled in Muskego, Wisconsin, Milk Can Hamburgers & Frozen Custard promises a culinary delight that brings together hearty burgers and indulgent frozen treats. Their menu features standout items like the classic burger, which captivates with its perfect meat-to-bun ratio and a balance of vibrant toppings. Sides like panko-breaded onion rings, served with a zesty horseradish dipping sauce, elevate the dining experience at just $4.99.
- Breakfast: Starting the day right with options like the Cinnamon Crunch Cold Brew Shake and delicious biscuits and gravy.
- Soups & Salads: Refreshing choices like the Door County Salad and comforting housemade chili provide variety.
- Frozen Custard: The sweet crown jewel that’s a must-try, leaving patrons satisfied and eager to return.
The inviting atmosphere and attentive service complete this memorable dining experience.
Fish Fry Dinners
Bowl Clam Chowder
New England Clam Chowder
3 Pc Fish Fry - Breaded
2 Pc Battered Fish
Gluten Free Friendly - Made With Milk Can Lager (Gluten Removed)
3 Pc Battered Fish
Gluten Free Friendly - Made With Milk Can Lager (Gluten Removed)
2 Pc Fish Fry - Breaded
Battered Fish Sandwich
Our Gluten Free Beer Battered Cod, American Cheese, Tarter Sauce and Dill Pickles on a Home-Style Bun.
Cup Clam Chowder
New England Clam Chowder
Southern Slaw Dog
Nathan's Premium Hot Dog, Creamy Coleslaw, Carolina Gold BBQ
Chili Dog
Nathan's Premium Hot Dog, Chili, Cheese Sauce, Split-Top Roll This item comes with the above listed ingredients. To modify your hot dog, please deselect the "everything" button and select only the toppings you DO want.
BBQ Chicken Bites-10 Peice
Hand Breaded Chicken Tenders Tossed in Sweet Baby Ray's BBQ. Served With Your Choice of Dipping Sauce.
Philly Cheesesteak Brat
Cheese, Bell Pepper and Onion Stuffed Brat Served on a Toasted Split Top Bun and Topped With Cheese Sauce, Onions and Bell Peppers. Onions Cannot be Removed From This Item.
Classic Hot Dog
Judy's Premium Hot Dog, Ketchup, Yellow Mustard, Split-Top Roll This item comes with the above listed ingredients. To modify your hot dog, please deselect the "everything" button and select only the toppings you DO want.
Garlic Parmesan Bites-6 Piece
Hand Breaded Chicken Tenders, Tossed In Garlic Parmesan Sauce. Served With Your Choice Of Dipping Sauce
Wisconsin Dog
Nathan's Premium Hot Dog, Ranch Cream Cheese, Dill Pickle, Split-Top Roll This item comes with the above listed ingredients. To modify your hot dog, please deselect the "everything" button and select only the toppings you DO want.
Spicy Chicken Bites-6 Piece
Hand-Breaded Chicken Tenders, Nashville Hot Oil, Choice of Dipping Sauce
Buffalo Chicken Bites-6 Piece
Hand Breaded Chicken Tenders, Tossed In Franks Red Hot Buffalo Sauce. Served With Your Choice Of Dipping Sauce
Classic Chicken Bites- 6 Piece
Hand-Breaded Chicken Tenders, Choice of Dipping Sauce
Spicy Chicken Bites-10 Piece
Hand-Breaded Chicken Tenders, Nashville Hot Oil, Choice of Dipping Sauce
BBQ Chicken Bites-6 Piece
Hand Breaded Chicken Tenders Tossed in Sweet Baby Ray's BBQ. Served With Your Choice of Dipping Sauce.
Classic Chicken Bites-10 Piece
Hand-Breaded Chicken Tenders, Choice of Dipping Sauce
Garlic Parmesan Bites-10 Piece
Hand Breaded Chicken Tenders, Tossed In Garlic Parmesan Sauce. Served With Your Choice Of Dipping Sauce
Buffalo Chicken Bites-10 Piece
Hand Breaded Chicken Tenders, Tossed In Franks Red Hot Buffalo Sauce. Served With Your Choice Of Dipping Sauce
Dogs & Bites
Beverages -
Decaf Coffee
Anodyne Decaf Coffee
Apple Juice Bottle
White Chocolate Mocha Shake
White Chocolate Shake With Anodyne Cold Brew
Large White Milk
Large Chocolate Milk
Tap Water
Fountain Drinks -
Large Orange Juice
Small Orange Juice
Cold Brew Coffee
Anodyne Cold Brew Coffee. Add in Your Favorite Flavored Syrups or Cream to Make it Your Own. Check Out Cold Brew Shakes in the Shake Section!
Bottled Water
Regular Coffee
Anodyne Milk Can Blend Coffee
Small White Milk
8 oz. Bottle of Sassy Cow 2% Milk
Small Chocolate Milk
8 oz. Bottle of Sassy Cow Chocolate Milk
Juice Box
8 oz. Fruit Punch Juice Box
Caramelized Banana Bread
A miniature loaf of our home-made banana bread drizzled with vanilla icing
Burrito
Scrambled Eggs, Tater Tots, Cheese Sauce, Grilled Onions & Poblano Peppers With Your Choice of Smoked Bacon, Turkey Sausage or Pork Sausage.
Bacon Side (3)
Breakfast Burger
Seared Smash Patty, Pepper Jack Cheese, Breakfast Sauce, Hard Cooked Egg, Tater Tots
Loaded Sides
Biscuit Side
Chicken Biscuit
Toasted Buttermilk Biscuit, Southern Fried Chicken, Breakfast Sauce and Pickles.
Pancakes (3)
Turkey Sausage Patties (2)
Classic Breakfast
Scrambled Eggs, 3 Strips of Applewood Smoked Bacon and 2 Pancakes
Tater Tots
Tater Tots, Seasoned Salt, Choice of Dipping Sauce
Choc Chip Pancakes (3)
Berry Stack Pancakes
3 Blueberry Pancakes, Fresh Blueberries & Strawberries, Strawberry Sauce, Whipped Cream & WI Butter
Add Pancakes (2)
2 Smaller Buttermilk Pancakes To Compliment Any Breakfast Item
Regular Coffee
Anodyne Milk Can Blend Coffee
English Muffin Side
Breakfast Tots
Seasoned Tater Tots Topped With Sausage Gravy, Scrambled Eggs, Cheddar Cheese and Scallions.
Decaf Coffee
Anodyne Decaf Coffee
Cronut Bites - 12 Piece
Croissant Doughnuts Tossed in Cinnamon and Sugar, and Served With Hot Fudge
Fresh Fruit
Caramelized Banana Bread - 4 Pack
Ham (Side)
Anodyne Cold Brew Shake
Anodyne Cold Brew Coffee Blended with our Vanilla Custard
Cold Brew Coffee
Anodyne Cold Brew Coffee. Add in Your Favorite Flavored Syrups or Cream to Make it Your Own. Check Out Cold Brew Shakes in the Shake Section!
Rise And Shine
Toasted Buttermilk Biscuit, Over Hard Egg, American Cheese, Smoked Bacon, Pork Sausage and Sausage Gravy
Wisconsin Breakfast
Scrambled Eggs, 2 Strips of Applewood Smoke Bacon, 2 Pork Sausage Patties and 2 Pancakes
Biscuits And Gravy
A House-Made Buttermilk Biscuit Topped With Sausage Gravy, Cheddar Cheese and Scallions.
BYO Breakfast Sandwich
House-made Buttermilk Biscuit or English Muffin, Over Hard Egg, American Cheese and Breakfast Sauce With Your Choice of Meats
Scrambled Eggs (2)
Cronut Bites - 6 Piece
Croissant Doughnuts Tossed in Cinnamon and Sugar, and Served With Hot Fudge
Cinnamon Crunch Cold Brew Shake
Vanilla Custard, Anodyne Cold Brew Coffee, Cinnamon Bun Syrup, Crushed Cinnamon Toast Crunch
Bread Pudding French Toast
Homemade Bread Pudding Soaked in French Toast Batter, Deep Fried, and Topped with Hot Fudge, Salted Caramel and Candied Pecans
White Chocolate Mocha Shake
White Chocolate Shake with Anodyne Cold Brew
Sausage Patties (2)
Breakfast
Custard Pints - Hard Packed & Ready To Travel!
Smores- Pint
Chocolate Custard with Toasted Marshmallow Syrup, Marshmallow Fluff, Graham Crackers & Chocolate Syrup
Snickers- Pint
Chocolate/Vanilla Swirl Custard, Snickers, Chocolate and Caramel Sauce
Unicorn - Pint
Cotton Candy Custard, Fruity Pebble Mousse, Rainbow Sprinkles, Fruity Pebble Rice Crispy Treats
Cookie Butter - Pint
Cookie Butter Custard, Cookie Butter Sauce And Cookie Butter Cookie Pieces
Bourbon Pecan- Pint
Vanilla Custard, Bourbon Syrup, Caramel Sauce and Candied Pecans
Banana Bread- Pint
Vanilla Custard, Banana Syrup, Banana Bread Pieces, Caramel & Chocolate Chips
Chocolate & Reese's - Pint
Chocolate Chips, Reese's Peanut Butter Cups, Chocolate Custard
Cotton Candy Marshmallow - Pint
Cotton Candy Custard With Mini Marshmallows & Rainbow Sprinkles
Cotton Candy - Pint
Cotton Candy Pieces With Cotton Candy Bites
Sour Smurf - Pint
Blue Raspberry Custard, Sour Blue Raspberry Gummy Bears And Mini Marshmallows
Blueberry Lemon - Pint
Blueberry Custard, Lemon Oreos & Blueberry Sauce
Strawberry Mango Crunch - Pint
Strawberry Custard, Strawberry Puree, Mango Puree & Fruity Pebbles
Peanut Butter Crunch - Pint
Vanilla Custard, Peanut Butter Crunch, Creamy Peanut Butter, Reese's Peanut Butter Cups
Chocolate Oreo- Pint
Chocolate Custard, Oreo Pieces
Red Raspberry - Pint
Vanilla Custard, Raspberry Puree
Strawberry Shortcake - Pint
Strawberry Custard, Strawberry Sauce & Shortcake Crumble
Snickers Brownie - Pint
Vanilla and Chocolate Custard Swirl, Snickers and Brownie Pieces, Caramel and Chocolate Sauce
Chocolate Delight- Pint
Chocolate Custard, Oreo Pieces, Brownie Bites, Chocolate Chips and Chocolate Sauce
German Chocolate Brownie - Pint
Chocolate Custard, German Chocolate Coconut Brownie Pieces & Chocolate Sauce
Vanilla - Pint
House Spun Vanilla Bean Custard
Raspberry Hazelnut - Pint
Hazelnut Custard, Raspberry Sauce & Hazelnut Pieces
Salted Caramel Pretzel - Pint
Vanilla Custard, Salted Caramel Sauce & Pretzel Bites
Orange Dreamsicle - Pint
Vanilla Custard With Orange Dreamsicle Syrup
Watermelon Jolly Rancher - Pint
Watermelon Custard With Watermelon Jolly Ranchers
Choc Covered Cherry - Pint
Cherry Custard, Chocolate Chips, Dried Cherries & Chocolate Sauce
Chocolate - Pint
House Spun Chocolate Custard
Fudge Brownie
House Made Fudge Brownie
Chocolate Chip Cookie
House Made Chocolate Chip Cookie. Served Warm.
Caramelized Banana Bread - 4 Pack
Cronut Bites - 6 Piece
Croissant Doughnuts Tossed in Cinnamon and Sugar, and Served With Hot Fudge
Cookies And Cream Cookie - 4 Pack
Cronut Bites - 12 Piece
Croissant Doughnuts Tossed in Cinnamon and Sugar, and Served With Hot Fudge
Chocolate Chip Cookie A La Mode
House Made Chocolate Chip Cookie. Served Warm with Vanilla Custard, Hot Fudge, Whipped Cream, Cherry
Caramelized Banana Bread
A miniature loaf of our home-made banana bread drizzled with vanilla icing
Chocolate Chip Cookie - 4 Pack
Peanut Butter Cookie - 4 Pack
Peanut Butter Cookie A La Mode
House Made Peanut Butter Cookie. Served Warm with Vanilla Custard, Hot Fudge, Whipped Cream, Cherry
Cronut Bites - 18 Piece
A Sharable Portion of Croissant Doughnuts Tossed in Cinnamon and Sugar, and Served With Hot Fudge.
Fudge Brownie A La Mode
House Made Fudge Brownie. Served Warm with Vanilla Custard, Hot Fudge, Whipped Cream, Cherry
Peanut Butter Cookie
House Made Peanut Butter Cookie. Served Warm.
Cookies And Cream Cookie
Cookies & Cream Cookie
Bakery & A La Mode
Soups & Salads
Turkey Cobb Salad
Roasted Turkey, Smoked Bacon, Hard Boiled Egg, Tomato, Cucumber, Red Onion, Avacado, Bleu Cheese, Seasoned Croutons and Ranch Dressing
Cup Chicken Tortilla
This Vegetarian Soup is Packed with Vegetables and Pasta in a Light Tomato Broth
Cup Of Chili
House-Made Spicy Chili, Sour Cream, Diced Raw Onion, Shredded Cheddar Cheese, Oyster Crackers
Bowl Of Chili
House-Made Spicy Chili, Sour Cream, Diced Raw Onion, Shredded Cheddar Cheese, Oyster Crackers
Door County Salad
Mixed Greens, Dried Cherries, Candied Pecans, Gorgonzola Cheese, Granny Smith Apple, Balsamic Vinaigrette
Cobb Salad
Chopped Romaine, Grilled Chicken, Bacon, Blue Cheese, Avocado, Egg, Cherry Tomato, Sliced Cucumber, Red Onion, Seasoned Croutons, Ranch Dressing
Cup Chicken Dumpling Soup
Side Salad
Mixed Greens, Sliced Cucumber, Cherry Tomato, Red Onion, Seasoned Croutons, Choice of Dressing This item comes with the above listed ingredients. To modify your salad, please deselect the "everything" button and select only the toppings you DO want.
Bowl Chicken Dumpling Soup
Bowl Chicken Tortilla
House Salad
Mixed Greens, Sliced Cucumber, Cherry Tomato, Red Onion, Seasoned Croutons, Choice of Dressing
Decaf Coffee
Anodyne Decaf Coffee
Large Chocolate Milk
Small Orange Juice
Small White Milk
8 oz. Bottle of Sassy Cow 2% Milk
White Chocolate Mocha Shake
White Chocolate Shake With Anodyne Cold Brew
Apple Juice Bottle
Small Chocolate Milk
8 oz. Bottle of Sassy Cow Chocolate Milk
Large White Milk
Tap Water
Cold Brew Coffee
Anodyne Cold Brew Coffee. Add in Your Favorite Flavored Syrups or Cream to Make it Your Own. Check Out Cold Brew Shakes in the Shake Section!
Large Orange Juice
Fountain Drinks -
Juice Box
8 oz. Fruit Punch Juice Box
Regular Coffee
Anodyne Milk Can Blend Coffee
Bottled Water
Beverages
Shakes, Malts & Floats
Chocolate Covered Strawberry Shake
Vanilla Custard, Chocolate Sauce, Strawberry Sauce and Brownie Bites
Large Root Beer Float
1 Scoop of Vanilla Custard, Explorium Root Beer
Regular Orange Dreamsicle Float
Large Shake
16oz Milkshake Choose from Chocolate, Vanilla, or Strawberry. Add toppings to create your own custom flavor!
Large Malt
16oz Malt Choose from Chocolate, Vanilla, or Strawberry. Add toppings to create your own custom flavor!
Anodyne Cold Brew Shake
Anodyne Cold Brew Coffee Blended with our Vanilla Custard
Regular Dr. Pepper Float
Large Orange Dreamsicle Float
Cookie Butter Shake
Vanilla Custard, Biscoff Cookie Butter, Graham Crackers
Cinnamon Crunch Cold Brew Shake
Vanilla Custard, Anodyne Cold Brew Coffee, Cinnamon Bun Syrup, Crushed Cinnamon Toast Crunch
Mint Brownie Shake
Mint Shake with Brownie Pieces
Cinnamon Bun Shake
Vanilla Custard, Cinnamon Bun Syrup, Crushed Cinnamon Toast Crunch Cereal
White Chocolate Mocha Shake
White Chocolate Shake With Anodyne Cold Brew
Large Dr. Pepper Float
Lucky Charm Shake
Marshmallow Shake Topped With Lucky Charm Marshmallows
Peanut Butter Bliss Shake
Vanilla Custard, Creamy Peanut Butter, Marshmallow Fluff, Crumbled Peanut Butter Cookie
Regular Root Beer Float
1 Scoop of Vanilla Custard, Explorium Root Beer
Cronut Bites - 6 Piece
Croissant Doughnuts Tossed in Cinnamon and Sugar, and Served With Hot Fudge
Cronut Bites - 12 Piece
Croissant Doughnuts Tossed in Cinnamon and Sugar, and Served With Hot Fudge
Cheese Curds
Beer Battered Cheese Curds, Buttermilk Ranch
GF Bun
French Fries
Fried Golden Brown And Tossed In Our Milk Can Seasoning Salt
Tater Tots
Tater Tots, Seasoned Salt, Choice of Dipping Sauce
Cheese Curds Family
Battered and Served With a Side of Ranch Dressing
Onion Rings
Panko Breaded and Tossed in Milk Can Seasoning Salt. Served With Horseradish Dipping Sauce.
Dressings & Sauces
Extra Dipping Sauces and Salad Dressings
Grilled Chicken Breast
Cronut Bites - 18 Piece
A Sharable Portion of Croissant Doughnuts Tossed in Cinnamon and Sugar, and Served With Hot Fudge.
Pretzel Bites
6 Buffalo Cream Cheese Stuffed Pretzel Bites Served With A Choice Of Dipping Sauce
Loaded Sides
Sides & Sauces
Sandwiches
Turkey Club
Sliced Turkey, Smoked Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato, Ranch Cream Cheese and Mixed Berry Jam on Toasted Multigrain Bread
Spicy Chicken Sandwich
4 oz. Hand-Breaded Chicken Breast, Nashville Hot Oil, Creamy Slaw, House Pickle, Spicy Mayo, Swiss Cheese, Sliced Tomato, Shredded Lettuce This item comes with the above listed ingredients. To modify your sandwich, please deselect the "everything" button and select only the toppings you DO want.
Blue Ribbon Ham Sandwich
Upoff Pulled Ham, Ranch Cream Cheese, Swiss Cheese, Dijionaise, Dill Pickle, Granny Smith Apple, Pretzel Bun This item comes with the above listed ingredients. To modify your sandwich, please deselect the "everything" button and select only the toppings you DO want.
Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
Buffalo Sauce, Ranch Dressing, Blue Cheese Crumbles, House-Made Pickles, Homestyle Bun
Classic Chicken Sandwich
4 oz. Hand-Breaded Chicken Breast, Hellmann's Mayo, Dill Pickle, Homestyle Bun This item comes with the above listed ingredients. To modify your sandwich, please deselect the "everything" button and select only the toppings you DO want.
Tuna Melt
Tuna Salad and Cheddar on Toasted Multigrain Bread
Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Pullman White Bread, American Cheese, Wisconsin Butter
Teriyaki Chicken
Fried or Griled Chicken, Sweet Teriyaki Sauce and an Asian Slaw on a Toasted Home-Style Bun
Battered Fish Sandwich
Our Gluten Free Beer Battered Cod, American Cheese, Tarter Sauce and Dill Pickles on a Home-Style Bun.
Hot Ham & Cheese
Uphoff Pulled Ham, Beer Cheese Sauce, Stone Ground Mustard, Hellmann's Mayo, Homestyle Bun This item comes with the above listed ingredients. To modify your sandwich, please deselect the "everything" button and select only the toppings you DO want.
Southern Chicken Sandwich
Fried Chicken Breast, American Cheese, Creamy Coleslaw, Dill Pickles, Carolina Gold BBQ, Homestyle Bun
Cali Chicken Sandwich
Fried Chicken Breast, Avocado, Mayo, Pickled Red Onion, Lettuce, Tomato, Homestyle Bun
Deluxe Chicken Sandwich
4 oz. Hand-Breaded Chicken Breast, Swiss Cheese, Hellmann's Mayo, Shredded Lettuce, Tomato, Dill Pickle, Homestyle Bun This item comes with the above listed ingredients. To modify your sandwich, please deselect the "everything" button and select only the toppings you DO want.
The Milk Can Melt
Seared Smash Burger Patties, American Cheese, Grilled Onion, Hellman's Mayo, White Bread This item comes with the above listed ingredients. To modify your sandwich, please deselect the "everything" button and select only the toppings you DO want.
The Milk Can Hamburger
Seared Smash Burger Patties, Ketchup, Yellow Mustard, Hellmann's Mayo, Grilled Onion, Dill Pickle, Homestyle Bun This item comes with the above listed ingredients. To modify your sandwich, please deselect the "everything" button and select only the toppings you DO want.
LegenDairy Burger
Seared Smash Burger Patties, Swiss Cheese, American Cheese, House-Made Cheese Curds, Grilled Onion, Dijonaisse, Pretzel Bun
The Milk Can Cheeseburger
Seared Smash Burger Patties, American Cheese, Ketchup, Yellow Mustard, Hellmann's Mayo, Grilled Onion, Dill Pickle, Homestyle Bun This item comes with the above listed ingredients. To modify your sandwich, please deselect the "everything" button and select only the toppings you DO want.
Jack's Gold
Seared Smash Burger Patties, American Cheese, Ranch Cream Cheese, BBQ Sauce, Onion Rings, Homestyle Bun This item comes with the above listed ingredients. To modify your sandwich, please deselect the "everything" button and select only the toppings you DO want.
Mushroom Swiss Burger
Seared Smash Burger Patties, Roasted Mushrooms, Swiss Cheese, Hellmann's Mayo on a Homestyle Bun
PB&J Burger
Seared Smash Burger Patties, American Cheese, House Made Bacon-Onion Jam, Creamy Peanut Butter, Homestyle Bun
Farmhouse Burger
Seared Smash Burger Patties, American Cheese, Dill Pickle, Pickled Red Onion, Lettuce, Tomato, Horseradish Sauce, Homestyle Bun
Jalapeno Popper Burger
A 1/4 lb Smash Patty Topped with Pepperjack Cheese, Smoked Bacon, Spicy Ranch and a Fried Jalapeno Popper Patty
Burgers
Snack Wraps
Buffalo
Buffalo Sauce, Bleu Cheese, Ranch Dressing, Lettuce and Tomato
Spicy
Nashville Hot Oil, Spicy Mayo, Creamy Coleslaw, Pickles, Lettuce and Tomato
Classic
Cheddar Cheese, Mayo, Lettuce and Tomato
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Cheddar Cheese, Crumbled Bacon, Ranch Dressing, Lettuce and Tomato